Home › Blogs › parakletos's blog

One Star

Mon, 10/13/2008 - 08:57 — parakletos

    I gave a one star rating to a story on SIYE because I though it was rubbish and it was more polite to give it a start rating than actually say what i thought and got this response:

    Author's Response: Thanks! I was hoping to find out there were some who really read the stories - It's great to REALLY know you can't make everyone happy!

    The story is HP& the Affairs of State and won an award in a recent challenge. Why I have no idea, but then I've never won anything, even losing a H&G fic vote to a R/H slash story.

    http://www.siye.co.uk/siye/viewstory.php?sid=128085

    Comments

    Mon, 10/13/2008 - 09:14 — melkior
    melkior's picture

    Winning...

    I once won a headache. Thankfully, the trophy wasn't permanent.

    Mon, 10/13/2008 - 11:28 — Kezzabear

    On the subject of SIYE Challenges ...

    I don't think I got over the last one I entered ... and I thought this Challenge was awful, awful, awful. I think I tried reading that story ... I think I even hated every single entry in that challenge ...

    You are brave putting that rating out there, I rarely get up the guts to rate them when they are that woeful now that it has my name attached - the author can respond to it and be sarcastic like in this case. I mean I know why it was set up this way but ... yeah a lot of stories have a very high rating because who wants to be the person who scored it so low?

    Well ... aren't I little miss sunshine today? :P

    Mon, 10/13/2008 - 13:02 — Jonathan_Avery
    Jonathan_Avery's picture

    Kezzabear wrote: You are

    Kezzabear wrote:

    You are brave putting that rating out there, I rarely get up the guts to rate them when they are that woeful now that it has my name attached - the author can respond to it and be sarcastic like in this case. I mean I know why it was set up this way but ... yeah a lot of stories have a very high rating because who wants to be the person who scored it so low?

    I have a lot of trouble leaving a negative review. And by negative, I mean something simple such as "I don't like this" or "This is horrible." or "Please hang yourself with your keyboard as you obviously have no literate use for it."

    I am a firm believer in constructive criticism, and I will always leave a review that points out the mistakes I saw and how the author can fix them. I will also, soften the blow with pointing out what they are doing well.

    If a story is so riddled with errors that the author would be better to burn it to the ground and move four miles to the west before writing again, I don't even comment on it. If the author can post such utter idiocy and still be proud of it, then anything I say will be as effective as howling at a banshee.

    Not to say that I am never tempted. Luckily, I just never ran across one while I was already bitter and disillusioned.

    -Jonathan

    - A good novel is an indivisible sum; every scene, sequence and passage of a good novel has to involve, contribute to and advance all three of its major attributes: theme, plot, characterization.
    Ayn Rand - The Romantic Manifesto p. 74 (pb 93)